LEAF logo
LEAF logo
DONATE
MENU
LEAF logo

Contact

DONATE
Informations en français
  • English
  • Français
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Mission & Vision
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Law Program Committee
    • FAQs
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Student Positions
  • Cases and Law Reform
    • Our Work
    • Issue Areas
      • Reproductive Justice
      • Indigenous Rights and Law
      • Identity-Based Oppression
      • Hate Speech and Online Hate
      • Sexual Assault and Consent Law
      • Gender-Based Violence
      • Access to Justice
      • Workplace Rights
      • Socio-Economic Rights
      • Family Law
    • Search Cases & Submissions
    • Current Work
      • Basic Income Project
      • LEAF’s Feminist Strategic Litigation Project
      • LEAF’s Technology-Facilitated Violence (TFV) Project
      • National Abortion Access Framework
      • Reproductive Justice Project
    • Past Projects
    • Legal Resources
  • Education
    • Overview
    • Workshops, trainings & webinars
    • Factsheets & infographics
  • News & Events
    • Search News & Events
    • Events
  • Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Working Papers
    • Reports
    • Annual Reports
  • Regional Branches
    • Overview
    • LEAF Edmonton
    • LEAF Halifax
    • LEAF Hamilton
    • LEAF Kingston
    • LEAF Ottawa
    • LEAF Québec
    • LEAF Thunder Bay
    • LEAF Toronto
    • LEAF Windsor
  • Get Involved
    • Ways to Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Join a Branch
    • Volunteer
    • Become a LEAF Pro Bono Lawyer
    • Partner with LEAF
Menu
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Mission & Vision
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Law Program Committee
    • FAQs
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Student Positions
  • Cases and Law Reform
    • Our Work
    • Issue Areas
      • Reproductive Justice
      • Indigenous Rights and Law
      • Identity-Based Oppression
      • Hate Speech and Online Hate
      • Sexual Assault and Consent Law
      • Gender-Based Violence
      • Access to Justice
      • Workplace Rights
      • Socio-Economic Rights
      • Family Law
    • Search Cases & Submissions
    • Current Work
      • Basic Income Project
      • LEAF’s Feminist Strategic Litigation Project
      • LEAF’s Technology-Facilitated Violence (TFV) Project
      • National Abortion Access Framework
      • Reproductive Justice Project
    • Past Projects
    • Legal Resources
  • Education
    • Overview
    • Workshops, trainings & webinars
    • Factsheets & infographics
  • News & Events
    • Search News & Events
    • Events
  • Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Working Papers
    • Reports
    • Annual Reports
  • Regional Branches
    • Overview
    • LEAF Edmonton
    • LEAF Halifax
    • LEAF Hamilton
    • LEAF Kingston
    • LEAF Ottawa
    • LEAF Québec
    • LEAF Thunder Bay
    • LEAF Toronto
    • LEAF Windsor
  • Get Involved
    • Ways to Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Join a Branch
    • Volunteer
    • Become a LEAF Pro Bono Lawyer
    • Partner with LEAF
Home / News & Events / Search News & Events

Case News

Supreme Court of Canada Decision Disappointing for Equality Rights and Access to Justice in Canadian Human Rights Commission v. Attorney General of Canada

Read the Canada (Human Rights Commission) v. Canada (A.G.) (2018) full case summary

Supreme Court of Canada Decision Disappointing for Equality Rights and Access to Justice in Canadian Human Rights Commission v. Attorney General of Canada, 2018 SCC 31.

On Thursday, June 14, 2018, the Supreme Court of Canada released its decision in Canadian Human Rights Commission v. Attorney General of Canada. The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) and the Native Women’s Association of Canada (NWAC) intervened in this case to advocate for First Nations women’s access to justice.

LEAF and NWAC are disappointed that the SCC endorsed a narrow interpretation of the Human Rights Act, and the corresponding role of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, which will limit the capacity of First Nations women to challenge the sexist registration provisions in the Indian Act. Despite the longstanding and incredibly damaging nature of this discrimination, the SCC endorsed the finding of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal that its statute does not allow it to consider challenges to the discriminatory registration provisions in the Indian Act, and has thereby closed an avenue for First Nations women and their families to achieve equality under the law.

The Decision under Appeal

The Appellants were two individuals who challenged the ongoing sex discrimination embedded in the Indian Act’s rules governing who can register for Indian status. The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal held that the proper venue to challenge the discriminatory denial of Indian status is not under human rights legislation, but under the Charter in a court of law.

The SCC found the Tribunal’s decision to be reasonable and upheld its finding that it did not have jurisdiction to consider the complaints.

LEAF and NWAC’s Intervention

LEAF and NWAC’s intervention argued that the Tribunal’s decision created significant barriers to access to justice and equality for human rights complainants, particularly First Nations women who experience sex discrimination under the Indian Act.

First Nations women have long been subject to sex discrimination under the registration provisions of the Indian Act, which has denied First Nations women access to services, benefits, and cultural identity and belonging. Virginia Lomax of NWAC states, “The significance of this discrimination cannot be understated. Various human rights bodies have confirmed that it is a root cause of the ongoing marginalization of First Nations women, including disproportionately high rates of incarceration, poverty, and violence. The government should eradicate this discrimination once and for all, but, failing that, the court system should seek to increase access to justice for First Nations women to challenge this discrimination, rather than erect barriers to human rights and equality protections.”

Historically, the Court system has failed to remedy this discrimination. LEAF and NWAC’s argument outlined the historic failure of the Court system in remedying this discrimination: First Nations women such as Mary Two–Axe Early, Jeannette Corbiere Lavell, Yvonne Bedard, Sandra Lovelace, Sharon Donna McIvor and more recently, Lynn Gehl were forced to engage in lengthy, expensive and difficult struggles for equality under the Indian Act, in the Canadian court system and at international rights bodies, none of which have eradicated the sexist registration rules altogether.

Karen Segal, counsel to LEAF, states “the SCC’s decision will continue to confine First Nations women to lengthy, expensive, and piecemeal complaints in the court system. We are disappointed that the SCC has cut off First Nations women’s access to a key venue to confront this discrimination, which will perpetuate sexism in the Indian Act and could ultimately have the effect of insulating discriminatory government legislation from human rights review.”

Notwithstanding this decision, LEAF and NWAC will continue their advocacy to promote equality for Indigenous women and girls and eradicate sex discrimination from the Indian Act once and for all. LEAF and NWAC wish to salute and offer gratitude to Jeremy Matson and his family for their determination and passion for equality. The time has now come for Canada to address the discrimination he and his family face under the Indian Act.

LEAF and NWAC’s factum is available here. LEAF is grateful to the counsel of Mary Eberts, alongside Kim Stanton of Goldblatt Partners and Virginia Lomax of NWAC, for their representation in this case.

About LEAF

Since April 17, 1985, when equality rights were enshrined in sections 15 and 28 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, LEAF has used litigation, law reform and public education to work toward equality for women and girls. LEAF intervenes in key cases to ensure that when courts interpret equality rights, there will be a systemic improvement in women’s lives. For more information about LEAF, visit www.leaf.ca.

About NWAC

NWAC has been advocating for the rights and wellbeing of First Nations, Inuit, and Metis women in Canada since 1974. Through grassroots engagement, policy and legislative analysis, and litigation, NWAC advocates to preserve Indigenous women’s cultures, families, and communities by elevating their voices to the national and international level.

Media

For media inquiries, please contact:

LEAF
Karen Segal, Counsel
[email protected]
416 595 7170, ext 226

NWAC
Virginia Lomax, Counsel
[email protected]

Read the full case summary
Let's Change The Law to Uphold Gender Equality
Donate
Join Us!

Related Project

Loading...
Multi ethnic group of Millennial investors planning new gainful activity
Current Work
LEAF’s Feminist Strategic Litigation Project

Related Cases

Loading...

Canadian Alliance for Sex Work Law Reform v. Canada (Attorney General)

This case is about the constitutionality of Criminal Code sex work provisions.

A.S. v. H.M.Q.

This case concerns the rights of complainants in sexual assault trials.
More Cases

Related Issue Area

Loading...

Access to Justice

LEAF_FAEJ_hz_names_colour_rgb_rev
Donate to support equality

National Office
180 Dundas Street West, Suite 1420
Toronto, ON M5G 1Z8
[email protected]
Phone: 416.595.7170
Toll-free: 1.888.824.5323
Facsimile: 416.595.7191

Stay up to date on feminist law and LEAF’s work to advance gender equality



LEAF_FAEJ_hz_names_colour_rgb_rev

National Office
180 Dundas Street West, Suite 1420
Toronto, ON M5G 1Z8
[email protected]
Phone: 416.595.7170
Toll-free: 1.888.824.5323
Facsimile: 416.595.7191

Charitable Registration Number: 10821 9916 RR0001

Facebook-f Twitter Instagram

Stay up to date on feminist law and LEAF’s work to advance gender equality



Donate to support equality

© 2020 Women’s Legal Education & Action Fund (LEAF). All rights reserved. | Legal & Privacy | Accessibility | Website by Affinity Bridge

MENU

  • About
    • Our Story
    • Mission & Vision
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Law Program Committee
    • FAQs
    • Employment Opportunities
    • Student Positions
  • Cases and Law Reform
    • Our Work
    • Issue Areas
      • Reproductive Justice
      • Indigenous Rights and Law
      • Identity-Based Oppression
      • Hate Speech and Online Hate
      • Sexual Assault and Consent Law
      • Gender-Based Violence
      • Access to Justice
      • Workplace Rights
      • Socio-Economic Rights
      • Family Law
    • Search Cases & Submissions
    • Current Work
      • Basic Income Project
      • LEAF’s Feminist Strategic Litigation Project
      • LEAF’s Technology-Facilitated Violence (TFV) Project
      • National Abortion Access Framework
      • Reproductive Justice Project
    • Past Projects
    • Legal Resources
  • Education
    • Overview
    • Workshops, trainings & webinars
    • Factsheets & infographics
  • News & Events
    • Search News & Events
    • Events
  • Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Working Papers
    • Reports
    • Annual Reports
  • Regional Branches
    • Overview
    • LEAF Edmonton
    • LEAF Halifax
    • LEAF Hamilton
    • LEAF Kingston
    • LEAF Ottawa
    • LEAF Québec
    • LEAF Thunder Bay
    • LEAF Toronto
    • LEAF Windsor
  • Get Involved
    • Ways to Get Involved
    • Donate
    • Join a Branch
    • Volunteer
    • Become a LEAF Pro Bono Lawyer
    • Partner with LEAF
  • English
  • Français