Content warning: sexual assault
Toronto, November 20, 2026 – The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) is pleased that a majority of the Supreme Court of Canada has taken steps to make instructions for jurors in sexual assault trials clearer and more accurate. R. v. Bilinski required the Supreme Court to consider whether and how to rid jury instructions of potential for bias rooted in myths and stereotypes about survivors of sexual assault. In a win for survivors, the Supreme Court identified where the potential for bias exists in jury instructions and took steps to prevent that bias from arising.
In this case, Mr. Bilinski removed his condom during intercourse, even though the complainant alleged that she had consented to intercourse only if a condom was used. The Crown alleged that Mr. Bilinski knew that the complainant did not consent to sex without a condom but removed it anyway. If a jury believed these allegations to have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, it would amount to sexual assault. Mr. Bilinski was acquitted by a jury at trial. The Alberta Court of Appeal then ordered a new trial, because it determined that the trial judge had not correctly provided the required instructions to the jury.
A juror’s job is difficult. In a sexual assault trial, a jury must wade through complex legal instruction while (usually) weighing one person’s word against another’s, all in the broader context of a culture that does not believe survivors.
Appropriate jury instructions are ones that are clear, accurate, and do not leave room for bias to inform a juror’s reasoning. In LEAF’s arguments in this case, we suggested language that would satisfy this criteria. Today, the Supreme Court took a step toward this ideal, clarifying the language in jury instructions, and in so doing, making sure that jurors are not permitted – consciously or unconsciously – to rely on culturally pervasive stereotypes when deciding whether someone is guilty of sexual assault.
“With this decision, the Supreme Court has removed an obstacle to survivors seeking justice in the criminal legal system,” says Cee Strauss, Senior Staff Lawyer at LEAF. “We recognize the tremendous amount of self-advocacy that survivors must do to be treated fairly in the criminal legal system, and hope that this increased clarity in the law can reduce the barriers that survivors experience in their communications with justice system actors.”
The Supreme Court also called attention – again – to the fact that consent requires communication, either by words or conduct. In other words, only yes means yes. In this case, the trial judge did not explicitly inform the jury of this fact when it was time for the jury to consider what the accused knew or didn’t know with respect to the complainant’s consent. According to the Supreme Court, without hearing from the judge that consent must be communicated, the jury might well have reasoned that the accused thought the complainant was consenting because she didn’t say no.
While LEAF celebrates much about the Supreme Court’s decision, the Court’s decision to set aside the jury’s acquittal now means that this case must be sent for a new trial. The events in question occurred in 2019, and the trial took place in 2023. LEAF regrets the workings of our criminal legal system, in which a finding of judicial error in sexual assault cases will often require survivors to re-experience the scrutinizing of their sexual assault in court.
This case was decided alongside a case raising similar issues, R v. Degale, in which LEAF did not intervene.
LEAF is grateful to have been represented by Neha Chugh (Chugh Law) and Reakash Walters (University of Ottawa) in this case.
LEAF’s interventions are guided, informed, and supported by case committees with relevant expertise. We are grateful to the case committee members for this intervention: Grace Ajele, Ula-Erin Chauvet, Daphne Gilbert, Jessica Jones, Saambavi Mano, Andie Marks, and Adriel Weaver.
For media inquiries, please contact [email protected].
-30-
About the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF)
The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF) is a national not-for-profit and charity that works to advance the equality rights of women, girls, trans, and non-binary people in Canada through litigation, law reform, and public legal education. Since 1985, LEAF has been involved in over 145 cases that have helped shape the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. To find out more, visit www.leaf.ca.